The Jews Of Venezuela

This past week four of us traveled on a solidarity mission to visit with the Jews of Caracas, Venezuela. I had the honor of traveling with Rabbi Avi Weiss, Gabe Ledeen of our congregation, and Rabbi Adam Scheier of Congregation Shaar Hashamayim in Montreal.

For the past few years we have been hearing of anti-Semitic attacks -- verbal and physical -- against the Jewish community of Venezuela and we felt the need to visit the community and express our solidarity with them.

There are three words that summarize what we saw in the Jewish community.

The first word is fear.

There is tremendous fear right now in Venezuela. In the general community there is fear, but that fear is greatly compounded in the Jewish community.

When I innocently asked someone if they were afraid, they said, “of course, we are all afraid.” Everyone we met withÑevery single person--expressed fear about the situation.

Here are some examples of how the fear has manifested itself:

During Israel’s recent war in Gaza, the Jewish schools remained open, but their school buses stopped running. The community felt it was too dangerous and too much of a target for children to go to school that way. The rhetoric of the government against Israel was too dangerous and incendiary.

Wherever we went, we felt that the Jewish community was literally under siege. Every Jewish institution is in a compound. When entering a Jewish organization, one must first go through enormous security -- a double door/wall entrance -- similar to the ones in prisons -- and a serpentine path to protect against terrorist attacks. Every Jewish facility is surrounded by very solid and high protective walls.

We were told by many members of the community that it was no longer safe to walk on the street. It was considered far too dangerous.

Leader after leader told us that Chavez not only created the climate for the attacks with his incendiary remarks but that he was also more directly responsible. For example, on the night of January 30 there was a terrible attack upon the Tifereth Israel Synagogue. It was a commando style operation involving 19 people and used sophisticated weapons to penetrate advanced security. When we met with the Cardinal of Venezuela he told us that government bandits were responsible for the attacks on the Jewish community.

The Jews of Venezuela are now living in a country that has state sponsored anti-Semitism and on top of that it is a country that has allied itself with Iran and Hezbollah. When you combine state sponsored terrorism and Hezbollah it makes for a potentially deadly combination.

It is no wonder then that when we met with the leaders of the major school in Venezuela we were told that their enrollment had dropped in half since Hugo Chavez had come to power. Almost the entire reason for this drop was because Jews had left the country in fear.

As the chief rabbi of the Ashkenazi community in Venezuela, Rabbi Pynchas Brenner, explained to us, “We are living with the fear of fear and it is scary.”

But with all that fear that we witnessed, the second word that comes to mind is courage.

We saw great courage.

When we met with the Cardinal of Venezuela, Jorge Urosa, (who is also the Archbishop of Caracas) he began the conversation by putting his cell phone in a different room so that the government would not be able to listen in. The cardinal is a very courageous man who has taken principled positions against the government even though he knows he is endangering his life. Around a year ago, the Papal Nuncio to Venezuela was outspoken against Chavez. Then one night a hand grenade was thrown over the wall of his residence. No one was hurt, but the message was clear.

Cardinal Urosa told us that Chavez personally attacks him on television in a very public and vile way, but despite these veiled personal threats against him, the Cardinal still speaks out publicly in support of the Jewish community. After the attack upon Tifereth Israel he immediately called leaders of the Jewish community is solidarity. He then issued a very great statement saying that an attack upon any synagogue is an attack upon every religion.

We saw courage amongst the people of the general Jewish community. We saw it in the Beit Shmuel synagogue where a hand grenade was thrown over the wall of the compound on February 26. Again, no one was hurt but the message was clear. The rabbi of the synagogue told us that he heard the explosion from his home four blocks away. He said that his kids woke up crying. Yet, in an amazing moment, when we walked into the synagogue that day on Shushan Purim, we saw a room full of people studying Torah. The hand grenade did not scare away the students of Torah. We davened together with these holy and brave Jews and then we sang and danced to the words of Am Yisrael Chai. Our dancing and singing carried out into the open plaza outside the synagogue. We danced around in circles over the very spot where the hand grenade had exploded.

And we saw tremendous courage in the leadership of the Jewish community of Venezuela.

The heart of the Venezuelan Jewish community is a complex known as Hebraica. Hebraica has a school that serves the needs of over 1500 children a day. In addition to its school it has enormous and beautiful facilitiesÑsoccer and baseball fields, tennis courts, bowling alleys, swimming pools, restaurants, and even a discotheque. On any given day there are thousands of Jews congregating there and using the facilities.

Since 2004, Hebraica has been raided twice by Chavez’ police. The first raid happened as the children were coming to school in the morning. The raid was ostensibly to search for terrorist weapons. But the leadership of the school told me that the police were actually only looking for places where they could plant the weapons. It is not a coincidence that the raid happened on November 29, the day Chavez visited Iran which is also International Palestinian Day. Chavez is using the Jews as pawns in his attempt to curry favors with others. The Jews are an easy target for him. And it is just the beginning. After the school was raided a second time, on December 1, 2007, this time the day before a national referendum, the policeman told the head of Hebraica: “The next time we will find what we are looking for.”

Hebraica is the nicest Jewish complex I have seen anywhere in my entire life. And yet, I had the terrible feeling that Chavez wanted to confiscate the whole property for his own political purposes.

During the recent war in Gaza, the leadership of the Jewish community met with Chavez and he told them to renounce Zionism and to criticize Israel. The Chavez regime has been enormously critical of Israel and has depicted them as a barbaric Nazi like state. For example, on the day we arrived we saw a state published newspaper showing a picture of a concentration camp with an Israeli flag flying over it and the caption: “New Administration.” The message of Chavez was that Israel is the new Nazi Germany.

When Chavez asked the leadership of the Jewish community to break with Israel, they responded: “We are a Zionist community and we will support Israel.” That is courage! To be able to say that to a dictator who is in total control of the country is extraordinary. At Hebraica we noticed that right next to the Venezuelan flag, the Israeli flag was flown proudly outside of the school in many places clearly visible to all. In the face of ruthless bullying this community is courageously standing up to the bully.

And one last word about courage. Some people have said to me, “Why don’t the Jews just leave?”

Many have left; perhaps half since Chavez came to power. Many others want to leave, but are concerned about the economic reality of starting over at this difficult time. But I also got a different sense when I met with leadership of the community. Venezuela just might be the most beautiful Jewish community I have ever seen. They are united, spirited, and they have built a beautiful infrastructure. To leave is to give victory to a bully. The courageous ones who have stayed are not naïve. They know how serious the situation is. But they also know that they do not want to give up on everything they have worked to build for the last 200 years. They do not want to run from a bully; they want to stand up to the bully.

And this brings us to the third word: responsibility. All of us outside of Venezuela now have a tremendous responsibility.

Over and over again we heard a simple but clear message: “We are very limited by what we can say, but we need you to return to your county and speak out strongly on our behalf.”

We have an enormous responsibility. The Jews of Venezuela were absolutely fine ten years ago. They were living in a beautiful country with tremendous security. Now an anti-Semite is intimidating them and we must assume responsibility. We must be the conscience of the world and speak out loudly on their behalf while demanding that others do so as well. We must literally be one with our brethren.

I will never forget one scene in particular. It was Shushan Purim and as we danced and sang to the words Am Yisrael Chai in the Beth Shmuel synagogue, the singing was suddenly stopped by an incredible rabbi who has been living in Venezuela for many years. He went to the middle of the circle and said, “There is a modern day Haman. His name also begins with an H. But we know that we will overcome him as well. In just one month we will read from the Haggadah where we recite the following words: ‘Bekhol dor vador omdim aleinu lechaloteinu ve-hakadosh barukh hu matzileinu miyadam, in every generation they stand against to destroy us, but Hashem saves us from their evil hands.’”

Yes we pray that Hashem may save us. But we need to do our part as well. We need to assume responsibility for our brethren, the Jewish community of Venezuela.